Offer of Spanish citizenship for Jews may require changes to achieve fairness

Reader comment on: Muslims Angry Over Spanish Citizenship for Jews

Submitted by Charles Stein, Dec 25, 2012 16:35

There are probably thousands of Sephardic Jews in the Americas and in Europe who are erroneously denied Spanish citizenship under the so-called Right of Return. The article states that " Anousim," the Jews who were forcibly converted to Christianity in Spain, are not entitled to return under the offer. It appears to make sense that under the limited offer of citizenship that Jews who are secular and unfamiliar with the Jewish faith should seek religious training and undergo formal conversion. However, descendants of Jews who were forcibly converted and secretly practiced their beloved faith in Spain and who were able to escape from the Spanish Inquisition to Holland, Italy, Greece, and Turkey and there resumed their Jewish faith should be granted full Spanish citizenship under the offer. This assumes that the present day descendants are practicing Jews.

Those descendants of Sephardic families that were forcibly converted to Christianity as stated above and are able to trace their return to the practice of Judaism in the Americas and Europe where they were welcomed, are entitled to the Right of Return. It's not that thousands will return; the principle is important! It is important to understand that thousands of Jews were forcibly converted during national riots in Spain in 1391. Many were slaughtered ninety years before the Spanish Inquisition was first implemented by King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella in 1481 and lasted for over 300 years.

Spain is a Catholic nation today , as it was during the hundreds of years of Jewish persecution. Credit must be given to the government of Spain for its efforts to give Spanish citizenship to the descendants of Spanish Jews. However, it has taken a long time for Spain to move forward from symbolic gestures.

In 1992 I was the Research Chairman of a Committee appointed by the Jewish Federation in Middlesex County, N.J. to commemorate the 500 th anniversary of the Expulsion of the Jews from Spain. An entire week was dedicated to: lectures, an original play, Sephardic music of the period, and other activities. I was privileged to write a letter to the King of Spain (without rancor) including a petition with many signatures requesting that King Carlos and his wife, the Queen, issue and declare a proclamation at the 1992 World Olympics, commemorating the contributions to Spain made by Jewish scholars, poets, writers, physicians, philosophers, diplomats, and advisors to the Crown and also to pay homage to the Anousim (the converted ones) of the Jewish people and others who suffered during the Inquisitions. Many Jews gave their lives to sanctify God's name.

I received a short, gracious letter from an advisor of the king stating that the king would appear at a Jewish synagogue in Spain and thank the Jewish people for their contributions to Spain, which he did.


Note: Reader comments are screened, and in some cases edited, before posting. Gatestone Institute reserves the right to reject anything found to be objectionable. Reader comments, including the one above, represent solely the opinion or viewpoint of the readers that submitted them and do not represent the opinion or viewpoint of Gatestone Institute. Gatestone Institute takes no responsibility for the content of reader comments.

Submit a comment on this article

Other reader comments on this item

Title By Date
Moslems came to Spain as conquerors [25 words]Doug ForbesNov 18, 2014 16:54
Hypocrisy [56 words]DougMay 28, 2014 11:57
Spain will be sorry [9 words]PhyllisFeb 2, 2014 17:15
Jews were not conquerers and persecutors of Christians.. Muslims were [30 words]Kbrt 111Aug 15, 2013 03:55
Al Andalus [47 words]lambsdorfJun 30, 2013 13:24
Original Documents [111 words]Sara FreifeldDec 30, 2012 10:39
Conversos [30 words]Aall55Dec 31, 2012 21:21
Suffering? [27 words]Aall55Dec 30, 2012 04:23
Moorish nerve! [178 words]L.J. GomezDec 27, 2012 20:12
The Romans are at it again - or, How to get 500 years of Jewish money we missed. [358 words]Filias FoggoiveyMar 7, 2013 06:12
Rectification: Difficulty/Usefulness [100 words]Julian TepperDec 26, 2012 10:59
Reaping What is Sown [218 words]John WhitbreadDec 26, 2012 07:07
⇒ Offer of Spanish citizenship for Jews may require changes to achieve fairness [468 words]Charles SteinDec 25, 2012 16:35
The Muslims want to invade us again [16 words]MinervaDec 25, 2012 15:12
Another attempt at weakening our moral!... [69 words]Jean-Paul RoufastDec 23, 2012 12:40
GIVE US A BREAK [64 words]Ray BossmanDec 23, 2012 12:12
The Muslims were invaders; the Jews were not! [36 words]KowalskiDec 22, 2012 10:28
They can start right away [35 words]YbyDec 22, 2012 08:00
Sweet [146 words]ZagreusDec 22, 2012 03:49
Islam was driven out of SPAIN in 1492 [94 words]Kenneth V. TELLISDec 21, 2012 16:52
Moriscos [47 words]Aall55Dec 21, 2012 16:52
They've got a point. [46 words]Empress TrudyDec 21, 2012 13:30
Moslems are complaining? [182 words]MichaelDec 21, 2012 12:57
Double standard one more time? [23 words]KraviDec 21, 2012 15:45
Spain and Jews [42 words]Lynne T.Dec 21, 2012 12:36
A Balance of Claims [204 words]Gleaner1Dec 21, 2012 11:46
Spain [41 words]Andy PaulDec 21, 2012 07:42
... And don't forget [86 words]A. M. GardnerDec 22, 2012 11:48
Spain: mediocre and unworthy. [160 words]AmàliaJan 16, 2013 20:13

Comment on this item

Email Address
Title of Comments

Note: Gatestone Institute greatly appreciates your comments. The editors reserve the right, however, not to publish comments containing: incitement to violence, profanity, or any broad-brush slurring of any race, ethnic group or religion. Gatestone also reserves the right to edit comments for length, clarity and grammar. All thoughtful suggestions and analyses will be gratefully considered. Commenters' email addresses will not be displayed publicly. Gatestone regrets that, because of the increasingly great volume of traffic, we are not able to publish them all.